In the 23+ Year History of the PJBT, below are the following bowlers who have the most titles in PJBT History.
The attachment below shows the tournament winners for every PJBT event since our inception in 1999.
| ALL-TIME SCRATCH DIVISION WINNERS | ALL-TIME HANDICAP DIVISION WINNERS | |||||
| 1 | JACK CELMER | 26 | 1 | SARAH FENICLE | 11 | |
| 2 | DARREN ZOMBRO III | 25 | T2 | DONNY MANNING | 9 | |
| 3 | TRAVIS CELMER | 24 | T2 | WALTER TOMLIN | 9 | |
| 4 | KEVIN BEERS | 20 | T4 | ERIN STRICKLAND | 8 | |
| T5 | AYDEN DAVIS | 18 | T4 | ALLISON STACKEWICZ | 8 | |
| T5 | JENNIFER SPARKS | 18 | 6 | ANDY HOFFMAN | 7 | |
| T5 | TYLER HERRMAN | 18 | T7 | BETHANY JAQUITH | 6 | |
| T8 | ALEX GLINSKI | 16 | T7 | BRIANNA STRICKLAND | 6 | |
| T8 | OWEN DARBY | 16 | T9 | JASON SNYDER | 5 | |
| T10 | DYLAN ZIMMERMAN | 15 | T9 | TAYLOR FORMAN | 5 | |
| T10 | RYAN WYANDT | 15 | T9 | BRAD REMP | 5 | |
| T12 | BRENT HIMMELREICH | 14 | T12 | ANDREW BARRON | 4 | |
| T12 | BRADLEY CROUSE | 14 | T12 | EVAN PERKOSKY | 4 | |
| T14 | BRANDON BOHN | 13 | T12 | CAMERON HAINES | 4 | |
| T14 | KOLBY BENNETT | 13 | T12 | SYDNEY HERRMAN | 4 | |
| T14 | DANIEL ALTHOUSE | 13 | T12 | ANNA COSTA | 4 | |
| T17 | MICHAEL MARTELL | 12 | T12 | BRIANNA BARNA | 4 | |
| T17 | JARRED POFF | 12 | T12 | JOSEPHINE BOOTH | 4 | |
| T17 | ERIC ERB | 12 | T12 | COBI KREMER | 4 | |
| T17 | BRYAN REINSEL | 12 | T12 | JASON WIER | 4 | |
| T21 | KURTIS STIDD | 11 | T12 | JAVION NORMAN | 4 | |
| T21 | ANTHONY NEUER | 11 | T12 | WREN WILLIAMSON | 4 | |
| T21 | BRANDON RUNK | 11 | T12 | RYAN FORRY | 4 | |
| T21 | JOEY OCELLO | 11 | T12 | MARIBETH BAKER | 4 | |
| T21 | JASON WEAVER | 11 | T12 | EMILY PHILLIPS | 4 | |
| T26 | BRIAN KENNEDY | 10 | T12 | BECKY GERHART | 4 | |
| T26 | MERLE BURKHART | 10 | T12 | STEVE RITZMAN | 4 | |
| T26 | LAYNE SANDT | 10 | T12 | SHAWN GERHARD | 4 | |
| T26 | JOEY BOFRONE | 10 | T12 | RILEY SMITH | 4 | |
| T12 | JACOB YODER | 4 |
